News
Manhattan judge acquits MIT brothers in $25M Ethereum MEV case
Judge Jessica Clarke acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of all charges over a 2023 exploit that drained $25 million from Ethereum trading bots. The case closes without a retrial.
HighRisk Media Newsroom, , 2 min read · Читать по-русски
Federal judge Jessica Clarke in Manhattan granted the defense's motion and acquitted brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of all charges: wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. According to Decrypt, the ruling was issued on Monday and closes a case in which a jury could not reach a verdict in November 2025, resulting in a mistrial.
How the attack worked
According to the ruling, the brothers placed bait transactions designed to lure specific bots. They then exploited a bug in a relay's code to see the bots' bundled trades before the block was committed. The bait transactions were then swapped for trades that sold tokens instead. Decrypt reports that the bots lost about $25 million in roughly 12 seconds. Authorities arrested the brothers in May 2024, saying the attack was planned for months and that the proceeds were concealed. At the Manhattan trial, an insider testified that the brothers had planned the attack. The defense had earlier sought to exclude evidence related to the defendants' Google searches.
Why the court found the charges unsustainable
The key point of the ruling is that a wire fraud conviction required proof of a material misrepresentation. Clarke found that none of the government's theories showed one. She described Ethereum as a "trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use." The brothers' conduct, she said, may have "frustrated the spirit" of MEV-Boost, software that lets Ethereum validators outsource transaction ordering to specialized block builders, but that was not enough to make out fraud. In a footnote, the judge said the prosecution "raises serious due process concerns," but did not rule on that question. The money laundering charge relied on proceeds of the alleged fraud, so it fell with the fraud counts. Decrypt also notes that the government itself called the case a "first of its kind" prosecution in its indictment.
What another source reports
Cointelegraph's article summary states that the judge found the transactions contained no false promises and stresses that the ruling does not determine whether the brothers' activity was ethical or violated other laws. The full Cointelegraph text was not available, so this account of the ruling relies on Decrypt's reporting.
Why it matters
- Breaking an expected transaction ordering is not, by itself, wire fraud without a material misrepresentation.
- The ruling is not a general permit for MEV strategies: the court did not assess them against other laws or ethical standards.
- The case closes without a retrial, but the court noted serious due process concerns without resolving them.
Sources
Prepared by AI from the sources above and checked against them (how we work). Spotted a mistake? Write to @highrisk_team.
Get stories like this first
- 📰 Daily briefing — Telegram channel @highrisk_media
- 📡 PSP and payment-method alerts — in our bot
- 🔒 HighRisk Private — closed chat with topics for iGaming, payments, crypto, dating, nutra
- 📄 Post your resume — seen by industry recruiters
MEVEthereumwire fraudcrypto lawcourt ruling
More in Crypto
· 1 min read
Deutsche Bank picks Crypto Finance for digital asset custody infrastructure· 1 min read
CoinDesk columnist: crypto exchanges should not combine trading and custody of client funds· 1 min read
Hong Kong urges banks to use AI to catch crypto crime early· 1 min read
Bullish reports Q3 net loss of $576.3 million as revenue beats estimates