Skip to content
highrisk.news
RUJoin

News

Visa and Mastercard Seek Approval of Swipe Fee Settlement in Brooklyn Court

Visa and Mastercard asked Judge Brian Cogan to approve their swipe fee settlement, opposed by Walmart, Circle K and NRF. No ruling yet; if approved, retailers could test refusing premium cards.

HighRisk Media Newsroom, , 2 min read · Читать по-русски

Visa and Mastercard Seek Approval of Swipe Fee Settlement in Brooklyn Court

Visa and Mastercard asked U.S. District Judge Brian Cogan on Monday, November 16, to grant final approval to a swipe fee settlement opposed by Walmart, Circle K and the National Retail Federation (NRF). The Brooklyn hearing ended without a ruling. If the judge approves the terms as drafted, retailers could test refusing premium consumer credit cards at selected stores while continuing to accept standard consumer cards from the same network. This is according to PYMNTS, citing hearing materials.

What Changes for Retailers

Under the terms, pilots are limited to 180 days in a 12-month period. A retailer can include up to 20% of its outlets under the same banner. A chain operating in at least five states can instead include all its same-banner outlets in up to two states, provided those stores account for no more than half of its outlets. Before a test starts, the retailer either provides a rollout schedule or gives the network and its acquirer at least 30 days' written notice identifying the test stores.

Pilots are not limited to premium cards. A retailer may also test refusing a network's commercial credit cards while continuing to accept its consumer cards, or combine the two options. A September PYMNTS Intelligence and PayPal study estimated that nearly 56 million U.S. consumers abandoned an online cart in the 30 days before the survey because their preferred payment method was unavailable. In stores, the pilots would show how often shoppers who intend to pay with a premium credit card complete the purchase with another method.

Disclosure and Discount Rules

Retailers must clearly disclose their card acceptance practices where they interact with customers or complete the sale. A merchant may explain that another card costs less to accept and ask the shopper to use it, but the wording must not suggest that the network made the refusal decision. Retailers may also offer a discount that varies by the issuing bank of a credit or debit card, while continuing to accept cards from other banks.

Costs for accepting consumer credit cards are capped under the proposed terms: posted interchange rates on standard consumer credit cards are limited to 1.25% for eight years.

Effective Dates

The approval date is defined as the first business day after the court enters judgment substantially in the proposed form and the required notice has been given to class members. Visa and Mastercard then have 90 days to amend the rules governing the pilots. The agreement sets a separate date for the settlement to become final once further court appeals are no longer possible.

Mithun Mansinghani, an attorney for Circle K and the National Association of Convenience Stores, said the agreement does not create meaningful competition among card issuers. Citing Reuters, CPI reported that retailers fear that even with the right to refuse, stores will face pressure to keep accepting premium cards.

Why it matters

  • The settlement defines which card types retailers can selectively decline at checkout, which directly affects payment acceptance terms in retail chains.
  • If the court approves the terms, payment networks must revise pilot rules within 90 days of the approval date.
  • Objections from Walmart, Circle K and NRF show that retail doubts the terms are enough to create real competition among card issuers.

Sources

Prepared by AI from the sources above and checked against them (how we work). Spotted a mistake? Write to @highrisk_team.

Get stories like this first

  • 📰 Daily briefing — Telegram channel @highrisk_media
  • 📡 PSP and payment-method alerts — in our bot
  • 🔒 HighRisk Private — closed chat with topics for iGaming, payments, crypto, dating, nutra
  • 📄 Post your resume — seen by industry recruiters

swipe feesVisaMastercardinterchangecard acceptanceretail payments

More in Fintech

All Fintech news